How Is Painting Plaster Different From Painting Drywall?

Two-story great room with tall painted paneled walls, built-in bookcases, a library balcony and large multi-pane windows

Plaster usually needs two things drywall doesn’t: crack and loose-plaster repair before any paint goes on, and a primer matched to its old coatings. Drywall needs less fixing, but its seams, nail pops and paper face have to be handled so they don’t show through the new finish.

Mount Kisco has plenty of both. About 15% of the village’s homes were built before 1940. Another 41% went up between 1960 and 1979, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (2019-2023). Much of the older group sits around the village center and has plaster on wood lath. Most of the 1960s and 1970s houses have drywall. Many houses from the decades in between have plaster over gypsum lath, which paints like plaster but tends to crack in straight lines where the boards meet.

We paint in Mount Kisco and next door in Bedford and New Castle. In every one of those houses, the first job is finding out what’s under the paint. Everything about the prep follows from that.

How can you tell whether a wall is plaster or drywall?

A light switch is the quickest way to tell plaster from drywall. Take the cover plate off and look at the cut edge of the wall around the box. Drywall shows a paper face over a chalky gypsum core. Plaster shows hard layers, and sometimes the wood lath behind them.

Two other tests take less than a minute. A pushpin slides into drywall with thumb pressure and stops cold on plaster. Knock along the wall, too: drywall sounds hollow between the studs, while plaster sounds dense almost everywhere.

Age is a decent clue, though it isn’t proof. Most houses built before the Second World War have plaster, and most built from the 1960s on have drywall. Houses from the 1940s and 1950s can go either way, and plenty of older houses have had a room or two redone in drywall since.

What changes in the prep for plaster and for drywall?

Plaster prep is mostly repair, because old plaster has had decades to crack, loosen and collect coatings new paint won’t grip. Drywall prep is mostly about hiding seams and fasteners, so the finish reads as one flat surface. Each item below is something we check before any paint goes on.

  • Loose plaster. Plaster grips wood lath through keys, the plaster that squeezed between the strips and hardened behind them. When keys break, the wall bulges or sounds hollow. We fasten it back with plaster washers or adhesive before any patching starts.
  • Hairline cracks in plaster. We open each crack slightly, bridge it with fiberglass mesh and fill it with setting compound. A dab of spackle over a moving crack usually cracks again.
  • Old coatings on plaster. Many older walls carry oil-based paint, and some ceilings still have calcimine, a chalky early finish. Oil-based paint gets scuffed and coated with a bonding primer. Calcimine gets washed off or sealed with a primer made for it, because new paint won’t stick to it.
  • Patches and stains on either wall. Fresh patches and old water stains get a sealing or stain-blocking primer, so they don’t show as dull spots or bleed through the finish.
  • Nail pops in drywall. Framing lumber shrinks and pushes nail heads out. We drive a screw beside each pop, reset the nail and spot it flat.
  • Drywall seams and tape. Tape that has bubbled or cracked gets cut out and redone. Ridged joints get sanded flush, gently, because the paper face fuzzes and tears if it’s sanded too hard.
  • Builder-flat paint on drywall. Many newer walls were finished with a thin, flat builder paint. Joint compound and paper soak up paint differently, so we prime the whole wall to keep the joints from showing as dull patches.

If you can’t tell what’s under your paint or how much plaster is still holding, we’ll check with you at a free in-home consultation. Call 1 (800) 687-9470.

Will plaster cracks come back after painting?

Hairline cracks in plaster can come back after painting, because the house keeps moving with the seasons and no paint or filler can stop that. Heating season is when it shows. Dry indoor air shrinks the wood framing and lath, and a crack filled in a humid month can open to a hairline again by midwinter.

We’ll tell you before we start which cracks are likely to come back, so they don’t surprise you next winter. Our written warranty leaves out cracks in drywall, plaster and wood for the same reason. They come from the house moving, and paint can’t hold a house still.

What we can control is how much the cracks show. Mesh keeps a repaired crack from reopening as easily. A wall with a web of cracks gets a full skim coat, so the repairs become one new surface instead of a scatter of patches.

Some cracks are a different matter: wide ones, diagonal ones running from a door corner, or one that arrives with a sticking door. Those deserve a structural look before anyone paints over them.

How we keep plaster repair clean in a lived-in house

Plaster repair makes dust, so we control it at the source. Air scrubbers run while we sand, which keeps dust and smell from drifting into the rest of the house. Every area we’re not working on stays covered until the room is done.

At Palette Pro Painting & Renovation, drywall and plaster repair is part of our interior painting service. Before the first day, a pre-production meeting settles which rooms we start in. Once we start, you get a daily update on what’s been repaired and what’s next. If a run of original casing has pulled away from cracked plaster, our carpenters reset it before the painters start.

The payoff comes after the skim coat and primer, when low winter light rakes across an old wall that finally reads flat. You’ll find more of our finished work in our before and after gallery.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is winter a good time to paint plaster walls in Mount Kisco?

Winter is a good time to paint plaster walls in Mount Kisco, because heating season opens hairline cracks to their widest. That makes them easier to find and fill. Cold outside doesn’t matter to interior paint, as long as the rooms stay heated to what the label calls for. Windows stay shut and air scrubbers run during sanding, so the rest of the house stays clean.

What paint will stick to old plaster?

Old plaster takes a quality acrylic latex paint well once it’s clean, sound and primed, and the primer does most of the gripping. Over old oil-based paint, we scuff the surface and use a bonding primer. To check what’s on your walls, rub a hidden spot with rubbing alcohol: if paint comes off on the cloth, it’s latex.

Can you put new plaster over painted walls?

New plaster or a skim coat can go over painted walls if the paint is sound. The surface gets scuffed and coated with a bonding agent first, so the new layer can grip. Loose or peeling paint has to come off, or the new layer will come away with it. Once the skim coat dries, it gets primed like any new wall.

How do you fix plaster that sounds hollow?

Plaster that sounds hollow has usually come loose from the lath behind it. While it’s still in one piece, it can be reattached with plaster washers or an injected adhesive. Once it’s fastened, we fill over the washers, skim the area flat and prime it with the rest of the wall. A section that has crumbled gets cut back to sound plaster and patched first.

Should old plaster be replaced with drywall before painting?

Old plaster rarely needs replacing before painting, since repair and a skim coat keep a harder, quieter wall and leave the casing alone. Tearing plaster out means demolition dust, new board and reset trim, which turns a paint job into a renovation. We suggest replacing it only where the plaster has failed across a whole wall or ceiling.

We’d rather spend an extra day on cracks than watch them show through a new finish by spring. Palette Pro Painting & Renovation has been doing that kind of prep across Westchester County, NY and Fairfield County, CT since 2009. Our 30-day follow-up and 12-month inspection matter on plaster in particular, since a full year of seasons is when movement shows. Call 1 (800) 687-9470 and we’ll come look at your walls.

Share with a friend:
Next Post
Is It Better to Spray or Brush Kitchen Cabinets?
Previous Post
Should You Refinish or Replace Your Kitchen Cabinets?
CT Home Improvement Contractor Reg. #HIC.0644304 | Westchester County Home Improvement License #WC-28105-H15